Children's COVID-19 risks unique, Chinese studies find
Filed Under: COVID-19
Mary Van Beusekom | News Writer | CIDRAP News | Mar 19, 2020
Editor's Note: This story was corrected on Mar 20 to note that, in the Nature Medicine study, children were less likely to die and have a symptomatic infection than older groups, as the original said they were more likely to die and have a symptomatic infection. We apologize for the error.
Emerging epidemiologic reports on COVID-19 in children in China show that, while they are less likely than adults to be infected and have severe illness, they are still vulnerable to the pandemic coronavirus.
Today, a large study published in today's Pediatrics showed that children of all ages in Wuhan and surrounding areas were susceptible to the COVID-19 virus, and one—a 14-year-old boy—died from it.
Also, in a letter on the severity of COVID-19 published in today's Nature Medicine, researchers reported finding that children in Wuhan were less likely to be infected by the virus and to die from it than were adults 30 to 59 years old.
And among 171 pediatric patients at a hospital in Wuhan, almost a quarter had no symptoms and only 1 died, according to a letter published yesterday in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM).
Less severe illness in kids, but no ages spared
In the Pediatrics study, researchers conducted the first retrospective epidemiologic analysis of disease spread and severity in 2,143 confirmed or possible pediatric COVID-19 infections reported to the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (China CDC) from Jan 16 to Feb 8.
Of the 2,143 cases, 731 (34.1%) were laboratory-confirmed, and 1,412 (65.9%) were suspected. Median patient age was 7 years (range, 1 day to 18 years); 1,213 (56.6%) were boys.
Using clinical signs, lab testing, and chest x-rays, the researchers classified 94 patients (4.4%) as asymptomatic, 1,091 (50.9%) having mild disease, and 831 (38.8%) having moderate illness.
Young children were more at risk of serious illness than older children were. The proportion of severe and critical cases was 10.6 % for children younger than 1 year, 7.3% for those 1 to 5, 4.2% for those 6 to 10, 4.1% for those 11 to 15, and 3.0% for those 16 to 18. "Only one child died, and most cases were mild, with much fewer severe and critical cases (5.9%) than adult patients (18.5%)," they wrote.
Despite that finding, investigators said that children of all ages and both sexes were clearly at risk due to the coronavirus. "Although clinical manifestations of children's COVID-19 cases were generally less severe than those of adult patients, young children, particularly infants, were vulnerable to infection," they wrote.
The authors write that the less severe presentation may be attributed to less exposure or sensitivity to COVID-19, different immune response mechanisms, or higher levels of antibodies to viruses than in adults due to broader exposures to respiratory infections in winter.
In a commentary in the same issue, Pediatrics editors Andrea Cruz, MD, MPH, and Steven Zeichner, MD, PhD, said that, while studies of pandemics often center on adults because they are economically productive, understanding that a disease affects adults and children differently "can yield important insights into disease pathogenesis, informing management and the development of therapeutics."
Median time from illness onset to diagnoses was 2 days (range, 0 to 42). Cases accumulated rapidly in Hubei province from mid-January to early February and then tapered off.
More children in Hubei were infected than those in other provinces, although the virus quickly spread to neighboring regions. The authors noted that children were unlikely to have visited the Wuhan seafood market at the origin of the outbreak. "There were more children infected in the areas around Hubei province than areas farther away, except for Heilongjiang province," they wrote.
"As most of these children were likely to expose themselves to family members and/or other children with COVID-19, it clearly indicates person-to-person transmission."
Lower likelihood of infection, death
Because people with mild infections were unlikely to have been tested in Wuhan's overwhelmed health system, researchers in the Nature study used the prevalence of infected travelers on commercial flights before Jan 19 and on charter flights from Jan 29 to Feb 4 to and from the city to estimate the disease's true prevalence. They also used data from the first 425 confirmed cases to estimate the rate of disease spread.
They found that people younger than 30 years were 40% less likely (0.6 times as likely; 95% confidence interval, 0.3 to 1.1) to die of the infection than those 30 to 59 years. And those older than 59 were 5.1 (4.2 to 6.1) times more likely to die. The risk of having symptoms increased with age—roughly 4% a year in adults 30 to 60 years.
The overall risk of dying after having symptoms of the coronavirus was 1.4% (0.9% to 2.1%). Mean time from illness onset to death was 20 days (17 to 24; standard deviation [SD], 10 days [7 to 14]).
People younger than 30 also were 84% less likely to have a symptomatic infection (0.16 as likely; 0.15 to 0.17) than those 30 to 59 years, while those older than 59 years were 2.0 (1.95 to 2.08) times more likely to have a symptomatic infection. Children, however, were more likely to have a symptomatic infection than were those 20 to 29.
"There is a clear and considerable age dependency in symptomatic infection (susceptibility) and outcome (fatality) risks, by multiple folds in each case," the investigators said. "Unlike any previously reported pandemic or seasonal influenza, we find that risk of symptomatic infection also increases with age, although this may be in part due to preferential ascertainment of older and thus more severe cases."
Understanding the range of symptoms, disease severity, and prognosis is crucial in triage and diagnosis, "especially in settings without ready access to laboratory testing or when surge capacity has been exceeded," the authors wrote. It also helps clinicians choose the best treatment and health system leaders to manage supplies and staff appropriately.
On a larger scale, estimating both diagnosed and undiagnosed infections helps inform public health containment strategies in light of the severe social and economic disruptions they are likely to cause, the authors wrote.
Only 1 death in 171 cases
In the NEJM study, researchers used data from the China CDC to assess symptomatic and asymptomatic children who had contact with people with confirmed or possible infection at Wuhan's only designated COVID-19 pediatric hospital.
Of the 1,391 children tested from Jan 28 to Feb 26, 171 (12.3%) had confirmed infection, and 1 (0.6%) died of the disease. Median age of infected children was 6.7 years.
Many (41.5%) had fever, and cough and throat redness were also common. Twenty-seven (15.8%) had no symptoms or signs of pneumonia on x-ray, while 12 (7.0%) had signs on x-ray but no symptoms, for an asymptomatic rate of 22.8%. "Determination of the transmission potential of these asymptomatic patients is important for guiding the development of measures to control the ongoing pandemic," the authors wrote.
Low lymphocyte levels were found in six patients (3.5%), while x-ray showed areas of fluid buildup in both lungs in 32.7%.
Three patients, all with underlying medical conditions, needed intensive care and mechanical ventilation. The comorbidities included hydronephrosis (enlarged kidney due to retention of urine), leukemia (including receipt of chemotherapy), and intussusception (intestinal blockage).
The child with intussusception, a 10-month-old, had multi-organ failure and died 4 weeks after hospital admission. As of Mar 8, 21 patients were in stable condition in non–intensive care unit beds, and 149 had been released, according to the letter.
SARS-CoV-2 Infection in Children
As of March 10, 2020, the 2019 novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) has been responsible for more than 110,000 infections and 4000 deaths worldwide, but data regarding the epidemiologic characteristics and clinical features of infected children are limited.1-3 A recent review of 72,314 cases by the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention showed that less than 1% of the cases were in children younger than 10 years of age.2 In order to determine the spectrum of disease in children, we evaluated children infected with SARS-CoV-2 and treated at the Wuhan Children’s Hospital, the only center assigned by the central government for treating infected children under 16 years of age in Wuhan. Both symptomatic and asymptomatic children with known contact with persons having confirmed or suspected SARS-CoV-2 infection were evaluated. Nasopharyngeal or throat swabs were obtained for detection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by established methods.4 The clinical outcomes were monitored up to March 8, 2020.
Epidemiologic Characteristics, Clinical Features, and Radiologic Findings of 171 Children with SARS-CoV-2 Infection.
Of the 1391 children assessed and tested from January 28 through February 26, 2020, a total of 171 (12.3%) were confirmed to have SARS-CoV-2 infection. Demographic data and clinical features are summarized in Table 1. (Details of the laboratory and radiologic findings are provided in the Supplementary Appendix, available with the full text of this letter at NEJM.org.) The median age of the infected children was 6.7 years. Fever was present in 41.5% of the children at any time during the illness. Other common signs and symptoms included cough and pharyngeal erythema. A total of 27 patients (15.8%) did not have any symptoms of infection or radiologic features of pneumonia. A total of 12 patients had radiologic features of pneumonia but did not have any symptoms of infection. During the course of hospitalization, 3 patients required intensive care support and invasive mechanical ventilation; all had coexisting conditions (hydronephrosis, leukemia [for which the patient was receiving maintenance chemotherapy], and intussusception). Lymphopenia (lymphocyte count, <1.2×109 per liter) was present in 6 patients (3.5%). The most common radiologic finding was bilateral ground-glass opacity (32.7%). As of March 8, 2020, there was one death. A 10-month-old child with intussusception had multiorgan failure and died 4 weeks after admission. A total of 21 patients were in stable condition in the general wards, and 149 have been discharged from the hospital.
This report describes a spectrum of illness from SARS-CoV-2 infection in children. In contrast with infected adults, most infected children appear to have a milder clinical course. Asymptomatic infections were not uncommon.2 Determination of the transmission potential of these asymptomatic patients is important for guiding the development of measures to control the ongoing pandemic.